Two kinds of potato
Starchy potatoes like russets feel dry and floury. Waxy potatoes like red ones feel moist and firm. The difference is inside the cells.
Fluffy cells pull apart
Starchy potato cells are packed with starch. When cooked, the starch swells and pushes cells apart. The potato breaks into soft, dry crumbs.
Firm cells hold on
Waxy potatoes hold less starch. Their cells stay glued together. They keep sharp edges in a long simmer.
Why fluffy potatoes take flavor
Loose, hot cells leave many tiny gaps. Seasoning flows into those gaps fast. Firm potatoes keep more of it on the surface.
Boil one russet and one red potato side by side. Press each with a fork. You will feel the difference.